Legal Malpractice Avoidance Checklist
The following checklists summarize some practical
suggestions to lawyers
on how to conduct their practice so as to
avoid claims against them for legal malpractice.
Contents
- Proper
Calendaring
- Non-Engagement
And Disengagement
- Avoid
Suing Clients For Fees
- Inadequate
Knowledge Of Law Or Facts
- A Good
Client Relationship Is Imperative
- Personal
Involvement With Clients
- Conflicts Of
Interest
- Malicious
Prosecution
- Financial
Matters
- Documentation
Or Leaving A Paper Trail
- Rejecting
Certain Clients And Cases
- What
To Do Upon Receipt Of A Malpractice Claim
- Client
Consultation
- Malpractice
Avoidance Techniques
1. PROPER
CALENDARING
Failure to properly calendar matters is the leading
cause of legal malpractice throughout the United States. Liability
is usually clear and the extent of damages is the major remaining
issue. There is little excuse for this type of malpractice so heed
the following suggestions.
- Calendar every case, not just those in litigation.
- Make or obtain a list of all critical litigation dates in your
jurisdiction and dual calendar them together with adequate lead
times.
- Have at least a dual caldendaring system with your secretary,
keeping a matched calendar.
- Provide all due dates and adequate lead times.
- Conduct a personal, monthly hands on review of all cases in
your charge to be sure each one is up to date.
Return
to Contents
2. NON-ENGAGEMENT AND
DISENGAGEMENT
Non-engagement is refusing to accept a case in the
first instance, and disengagement is removing yourself from the case
after having once accepted it. Horrendous claims have arisen because
attorneys did not properly exit from a case. In rejecting a case or
withdrawing, consider each of the following points.
- The attorney's withdrawal should be confirmed by a certified
letter to the client return receipt requested.
- The letter should state, in no uncertain terms, that the law
firm is not taking or going to continue representing the client in
that case.
- The client should be advised that there are critical time
limits that must be adhered to in order to keep a claim viable.
- The client should be advised to seek other legal counsel as
soon as possible to pursue his rights.
- Avoid stating the exact legal reason for rejection of the
case.
- Avoid stating why, in your opinion, the case lacks merit.
- Avoid stating why, in your opinion, certain defendants are not
liable.
- If you have become attorney of record in the case, then a
substitution of attorneys must be obtained by client consent or a
court order obtained releasing you from the case.
Return
to Contents
3. AVOID SUING CLIENTS FOR
FEES
Experience has shown that a great many legal
malpractice cross-complaints are filed in response to the attorney's
suit for unpaid fees. Often, the fees were not properly established,
billed or collected prior to the litigation. Heed the following
warnings.
- As a general rule, avoid suing clients for fees.
- The preventive fee arrangement: By carefully handling your
fees from the outset of a new case, the need to sue a client can
often be avoided.
Is a substantial amount of money involved insofar
as your law firm is concerned?
Return
to Contents
4. INADEQUATE
KNOWLEDGE OF LAW OR FACTS OF THE CASE.
Attorneys who take on a new matter in which they lack
experience are generally held to the standard of care practices by
those attorneys who practice in that area of law as one of their
specialties. With that in mind, attorneys should move into new areas
of legal practice with caution.
- Refer to or associate with an expert if you lack the necessary
expertise.
- Attend continuing education law courses in your fields of
practice.
- Keep current with the changes in the law.
- Make a thorough independent investigation of the facts, do not
rely solely upon the client's version.
- Conduct reasonable research on all of the pertinent issues.
Return
to Contents
5. A GOOD CLIENT
RELATIONSHIP IS IMPERATIVE
Every attorney will make mistakes, but not all will be
sued. Often, the difference has to do with the strength of the
attorney-client relationship. Experience has shown that the
checklist items set forth below are important considerations in
establishing the appropriate attorney-client relationship.
- Understand and mutually define your client's objectives.
- Develop a case plan or transaction plan with each client. Give
client a copy.
- Review and make sure the client understands the risks in any
procedure or action you recommend. Suggest commercially acceptable
solutions.
- Have each client sign a representative agreement and make sure
the client understands the fee arrangement and the agreement.
Advise that you will bill periodically, preferably monthly.
- Define the client's responsibilities and encourage realistic
expectations in the client. Show an interest in the client as a
person.
- Define the lawyer's responsibilities.
- Be on time for appointments, if it is in your office, greet
the client in the reception area and make sure the client feels at
ease and comfortable.
- Return all phone calls promptly.
- Avoid taking telephone calls during office conferences with
the client.
- Copy your client with your work product.
- Keep all promises.
Return
to Contents
6. PERSONAL OR FINANCIAL
INVOLVEMENT WITH CLIENTS
When something goes wrong with a business investment
in which the attorney is a partner with the client, very often the
attorney is brought into the litigation on a malpractice cause of
action. In many cases, such participation by an attorney may not be
covered by a malpractice policy.
Sexual involvement, either actual or implied, during
representation aggravates any type of malpractice case.
- Do not encourage clients to invest in projects.
- Do not accept stock in lieu of fees.
- Do not personally guarantee a client's obligations or have the
client personally guarantee yours.
- Avoid advancing costs where possible.
- Avoid dating or having an intimate relationship with a client
during the course of your representation.
Return
to Contents
7. CONFLICT OF
INTEREST
Many problems arise out of the discovery of a conflict
of interest after a case has been commenced. One of the hazards of
continuing the representation is that the attorney may have to
return all fees received and incur responsibility for client's other
damages.
- Establish a "fail safe" conflict system within the office.
- Avoid suing prior clients even when allowed under the rules.
- Take only one side in a dispute.
- Receive your compensation in a transaction from only one side.
- Avoid being both a director and an attorney for a business
entity.
- Where allowed, consider written waiver of conflict by the
parties affected.
- Do not represent buyer and seller, landlord and tenant or
trustor and beneficiary at the same time.
- Set forth who you represent in any document that you draft
and, where appropriate, indicate that the other party has been
advised to seek independent counsel.
- Do not act as an escrow agent in connection with the sale of
real estate or a business.
- Do no accept employment from more than one client seeking to
sue and collect from a single source without a specific written
agreement from all plaintiffs as to how the proceeds are to be
divided.
Return
to Contents
8. MALICIOUS
PROSECUTION
Malicious prosecution is not malpractice per se
because it involves an intentional tort brought by a third party,
not by the client. At the same time, being sued for malicious
prosecution has the same emotional and financial impact on the
attorney as a pure legal malpractice claim. Consider the practical
suggestions set forth below to avoid finding yourself becoming a
defendant in such a case.
- Do not name parties as defendants without reasonable research
and investigation.
- Reject grudge lawsuits.
- Avoid, where possible, suing other attorneys.
Return
to Contents
9. FINANCIAL
MATTERS
Many large claims are appearing because attorneys are
not watching out for the financial protections of their clients.
- Recommend adequate security where appropriate.
- Properly perfect any security document given to your client.
- Provide protection of cash payments through an escrow account
where appropriate.
- If your client is sued in a liability case, make sure that all
of the client's insurance policies are considered in providing
defense and/or indemnity protection.
Return
to Contents
10. DOCUMENTATION OR
LEAVING A PAPER TRAIL
Lack of documentation may give rise to a claim that
would otherwise never exist. Often, after things go bad the client
will remember advice given (or not given) in a completely different
way than will the attorney.
- All important advice to the client should be confirmed in
writing.
- It is critical to write to the client when the client is
proceeding contrary to the lawyer's advice.
- Matters of less importance may be covered by memorandum to the
file.
- It is important to document all settlements offered and
rejected and to have them signed by the client.
Return
to Contents
11. REJECTING CERTAIN
CLIENTS AND CASES
As attorneys gain experience, they learn that certain
clients and certain cases are better off rejected at the outset.
Some red flag warnings follow:
- Beware of the client who is changing attorneys.
- Look out for the case that has already been rejected by one or
more other firms.
- Avoid the case that has an element of unavoidable urgency.
- Beware of the client who has already contacted multiple
government representatives to plead his case.
- Beware of the client who wants to proceed with his case
because of principle and regardless of cost.
- Beware of a client who has done considerable legal research in
propria personal on his case.
- Beware of the client who is obviously recognizable as being
impaired by chemical substances, alcohol, drugs, etc.
- If your first impression of the client or his course of action
is unfavorable, think twice before accepting his case.
- If you and your client cannot easily agree on fee and
retainer, you may be dealing with a difficult client.
Return
to Contents
12. WHAT TO DO UPON
RECEIPT OF A MALPRACTICE CLAIM
Attorneys, upon receiving a malpractice claim or the
suggestion of a claim from a client, sometimes fail to report the
incident immediately in hopes of rectifying the situation on their
own without upsetting their partners.
- If an actual claim (suit), report the claim as soon as
possible in accordance with the provisions of your policy.
- If an incident occurs and you feel that it could eventually
result in a claim, discuss the situation with a partner in the
firm and report it to the carrier under the "Discovery" clause of
your policy.
- Discuss the alleged claim or incident with an experienced
attorney that you respect.
- Explore, with your carrier, whether or not the alleged mistake
can be corrected by any means.
- If it is a relatively small claim, try and have it settled
quickly, withing the amount of your deductible.
- Try and resolve the claim by settlement rather than by trial.
- Do not represent yourself.
- If the case proceeds to litigation, try every method of
winning the case, jury trial being the last resort.
- Consider, if the possibility exists, having the case litigated
in a county other than your own to avoid unnecessary publicity.
- Be completely hones and cooperative with your defense counsel.
Return
to Contents
13. CLIENT
CONSULTATION
Failure to obtain client consent endangers the
harmonious client attorney relationship. If the client becomes angry
with the attorney, or feels that the attorney is proceeding without
his consultation, that client is more likely to become dissatisfied
and consider suing if he/she does not obtain the case result he/she
desires. Do not proceed in a vital area of a case or matter,
including the following, without your client's express permission.
- Extending to the other side additional time in which to
respond to a pleading.
- Stipulating to a given item of testimony or evidence.
- Settling a case.
- Suggesting a settlement figure to the other side.
- Rejecting a settlement offer.
- Agreeing to a continuance.
- Concluding your client's testimony in a litigation matter
without checking with the client to see if he has additional
testimony to impart.
Return
to Contents
14. MISCELLANEOUS
MALPRACTICE ADVICE
In addition to the foregoing, there are some practical
suggestions that do not fit into any of the preceding categories,
but are nevertheless extremely important.
- In drafting legal documents, us a comprehensive up-to-date
checklist as a guideline to your own document whenever possible.
- Do not accept cases for which you do not have either adequate
time or capital to take the case to its completion.
- Screen out cases with poor liability early because those tend
to be the cases where a statute of limitations is missed.
- If you are a new attorney, arrange to have access to a
"mentor" attorney with whom you can talk over new legal and
practical case control problems.
- If you are not practicing in partnership for, make your
independent status form, make your independent status clear to
your clients, and makes sure that your associates do so as well to
avoid liability on the theory of a "defacto partnership".
- If you suspect that you or a legal associate has a drinking or
a drug problem, get professional help at once.
- Any error that you wish to argue on appeal must be properly
presented and preserved in the record of the trial court
proceedings.
- Reinforce the elements of your firm's client service strategy
at an annual retreat with everyone in the firm.
- Reward employees for being client advocates.
Return
to Contents
CAUTION:
The information contained on this page is
intended solely as general loss prevention advice and not as legal advice for dealing with any
specific legal problem.